


Out of the mouths of baby-headed chumps.

'....a completely political exercise, excluding the view of the great mainstream of the Australian people, putting together a bunch of elites and trying to make it look respectable.'
What am I, your social calendar? Go outside and play some stick-ball.
Ill-informed rantings and half-baked theories from someone who should know better.




All post text © copyright Ms Fits 2003–2010. Site designed by Inventive Labs.
Comments
Mr. Downer. FYI, i think these 'bunch of elites' represent more of the view of the 'great mainstream of the Australian people' than a far from 'elite' liberal party.
Pot calling kettle.
Come in Kettle.
Over.
That's kind of the point, Benj.
Well noted, though.
Darts?
Australia's leading free market think tank.
Mr. Downer is definately a glass half full type of guy. Either that or he really enjoys the Queen tickling his ear.
bring it on!
Say what you will about him, he's done a lot for this country, for domestic violence and for curly hair.
Plus, he's dealing with an overwhelming sense of irrelevance. Maybe we should be taking it easy on him.
pray, how the fuck is fits a member of the cultural elite?
Crinton the difference might just be that Fits doesn't run around moaning about the 'cultural elite' when things don't go her way.
But Fits spent years moaning about the political elite when things weren't going her way. I'm not saying that I disagreed with a lot of what she said but you can't deny my point.
Anonymous said...
how does one join the cultural elite? is there an application form? a secret handshake?
pray, how the fuck is fits a member of the cultural elite?
She is a published writer, a newspaper columnist and a national radio presenter who makes regular TV appearances where she discusses books. How is she not a member of the cultural elite? I'm not attacking Fitz and I don't like the monarchy either but what makes Fitz less elite than Lexie?
Having an opinion on a book does not make you a 'cultural elite', Crinton. It just makes you someone who's read a book.
Nowhere near as good however, as Nelson on ABC Radio Saturday.
When asked what he thought of 2020 so far, he replied that it was "a bit of a schamozzle". Did he have any ideas he wanted to contribute to the summit? "Well I'm hardly going to come here and tell Kevin Rudd".
So not only is his grasp of the English Language comparable with that of my 5 year old niece, he plays just as well with the other kids as she does...
How anybody can whinge about elites at a monarchists convention is beyond me too.
Lots of nodding grey hair and walking frames. (If you look closely I think you even can see an elderly lady doing her knitting)
Perhaps you shouldn't just accept that 'they' exist based on Downer et al using the term. I'm yet to hear what this group's agenda is - it just seems to be a pejorative which is occasionally tossed over the political fence.
Nice cheap shot about 'total agreement' though.
By definition anyone doing anything well is a member of an 'elite', and so... SO?
*an observation*
Hey, here's a crazy thought. Maybe there's no such thing as the 'cultural elite'. Maybe it's just a divisive term cooked up in some sinister political laboratory.
Don't think it's crazy. One nasty aussie trait is a wierd hatred of elites in anything but sport. Tar your opponents with elitism and you capture the same folks who get sucked in by Hanson and shock-jocks. Sad but true I fear.
You'd be amazed at how many artists come from working class backgrounds.
Therefore, quite a lot of your supposed 'elite culture' is supplied by the working class. And the working class is hardly 'elite'.
The elite rich just fund (some of) the culture.
Seems to me Fitz dislikes the political elite (of the right) asmuch as Downer hates the cultural elite. You've just proved my argument.
I don't hate the "elite". I admire anyone who has achieved something in life and Australia wouldn't be the country it is without them. Sublime-ation, my argument that she is part of a cultural elite is a complement not a criticism. If she didn't have such a clever brain she wouldn't have her prominent position in the arts and wouldn't have been part of the summit. But you can't really argue Fitz is a member of the working class. Unquestioning agreement really is compulsory here.
"...it was good, I think. Among other small victories, it's blown away Howardism forever, and swept our tribal mind clean of his dreary aroma. Howard's most singular achievement was to squeeze down -- or dumb down, the neologism is appropriate in this case -- the National Conversation to only one question, really, which is what group will we single out this week, my fellow Australians, to sneer at, villainise, disdain, sideline and persecute? Aborigines? Boat people? Pregnant lesbians? State schoolteachers? ABC broadcasters? Muslim clerics? Andrew Wilkie? Michael Kirby? Leunig?
And Rudd this weekend showed how many conversations there are, and how many questions there are. And to see so many people, so exultantly, so abundantly, so self-confidently, so recklessly, throwing up new ideas like confetti, was to wonder how did this happen? How did Howard's Australia, which was grey, suspicious, reclusive, selfish, mendacious and melancholy, so quickly become this convivial, comradely, jovial, self-mocking and plain-speaking miracle of last weekend?
It's called freedom of speech, I guess.
And it's good to have it back."
- from his column at Unleashed.
This 'cultural elite' stuff is bullshit.
You'd be amazed at how many artists come from working class backgrounds.
Therefore, quite a lot of your supposed 'elite culture' is supplied by the working class. And the working class is hardly 'elite'.
The elite rich just fund (some of) the culture.
So your definition of elite includes class? Specifically not working class?
Working class folks are never elite?
Huh?
*exits humming old john lennon song*
*exits humming old john lennon song*
Please tell me it was "Lucy in the sky with diamonds".
Denny Crane.
Denny Crane.
Denny Crane.
Alexander is attempting to establish firstly that there are "elites", secondly that the appropriate collective noun is bunch and lastly that such a group is inherently disrespectable.
I think he got it right apart from the collective noun. how about herd?
Perhaps a "condescension of elites"?
What am I, a dictionary? Look it up yourself.
No one ever tells me so what am I to know.
What am I, a dictionary? Look it up yourself.
Gadzukes! You're right! But me thinks class is referring to classification not class structure of society in the definition - always 'group or class' of...
My objection to 'working class' is akin to it being a 'caste' from which you cannot escape rather than simply an incidental of occupation. Where 'elite' is by your definition (not the dictionary) never from the working class 'caste'.
Perhaps I'm being idiosyncratic... wouldn't be the first time.
There was more than a similarity and I’ve got to say that whilst I have a high regard for all of those who came to the conference, it seemed not to be fully representative of Australian society. I met the representative of the sex workers, I met the secretary of the Maritime Union of Australia but it was much more difficult to find small businessmen and women and the Australian Medical Association.
I think Nel-Dog's version is funnier because he implies he sought out Elena Jeffrys with the same tenacity with which he did the small businessmen and women.
What the...???
With blackjack, and hookers.
On second thought, screw the elite.
Daddy tell them....
As far as "Freedom of Speech" give me a break, There hasn't been a government over the last 40 years where Australians didn't enjoy Freedom of Speech. What the fuck is it with left wing/right wing knobs and hyperbole?
http://www.news.com.au/couriermail/story/0,23739,23580010-5003402,00.html
Denny Crane.
If, from any observer's P.O.V, an"elite" is a group of which they are not a member then, sure, it was surely a fine collection assembled.
And we can't only judge the event's worth purely by changes in official policy. At least a few of the attendees may have taken something from it....
and all their comments are as boring as batshit ...
Im starting my own elite, and youse are welcome to apply. But I will probably reject most of you because there's only room for me.
And my chickens.
And what about if you step back from it all, Crinton - remove the assumption that there IS an elite with an agenda, while retaining the quite sensible thought that people around the world excel in different areas. Where does that leave you?
I think you're suffering a basic confusion between the idea of excellence (someone who is elite in their field) with the dismissive 'cultural elite' who are, apparently, pursuing agendas on both sides of politics.
Incidentally, your grasp of logic stinks.
Kind regards, etc...
I know the pot calling kettle was the point. I'm not quite that retarded.
Rather, I heard that quote the other day, and have been dying to use it.
Perhaps it was a little bit obvious to the cultural elite reading this blog *tongue wedged firmly in cheek*
A/ Fits is NOT from a working class background (nothing wrong with that)
B/ She is not one of the 1000 keenest minds in the country (no offence intended as I am sure she would say the same)
C/ Kram went. (no offence either but where he fits in as an elite is anyone's guess)
Hmmm. Wait a minute. I've had another thought - perhaps 'an elite' is just another term for 'someone else'. More specifically, 'someone else I don't like'. I can't imagine anyone describing themselves as an elite - can you?
And what about if you step back from it all, Crinton - remove the assumption that there IS an elite with an agenda, while retaining the quite sensible thought that people around the world excel in different areas. Where does that leave you?
I think you're suffering a basic confusion between the idea of excellence (someone who is elite in their field) with the dismissive 'cultural elite' who are, apparently, pursuing agendas on both sides of politics.
Incidentally, your grasp of logic stinks.
Kind regards, etc...
Booky, your lack of decorum and inability to even consider a divergent point of view sucks ass. You seem to think my comments about the cultural elite are motivated by jealousy but as I said earlier, I don't see the term as a perjorative one unlike Downer. You wrongly think I have adopted Downer's criticism. I say you can't deny Fitz is a leading member of an Australian cultural elite. The efforts of you and a few others to defend Fitz from what you all perceive as an attack says alot about the culture of this website.
Sublime-ation, upper class is still upper class whether it's Adelaide old money or the rewards that come from being a part of a family that has been among the cream of the Australian artistic community for decades.
Here, you work every day of your life and try to struggle through uni to get a wiff of a chance to become an academic you fucktard BoBo. Your not even good for BoBo, because there is no Boheme in your Bourgeise.... just disgusting white rich trash for generations and generations..... take a smell from my oilly oilly rag, its the latest trend amongst us elites.
GET FUCKED AND DIE LIKE SOMETHING OUTTA SAW 4 FUCKER
What I don't understand is why you're trying to make the point that there is such a thing as a 'cultural elite' group, and why it's important if Fits is in it. Who else is in the group? Good cooks? Kindergarten teachers? Brickies? Ita Buttrose?
My point is that any group referred to as 'culturally elite' will be so subjective as to be ridiculous - as it is with Downer's rubbish statements, it's always 'others'. And the only point of constructing such a group is to make generalisations about it - so why bother?
Do you want me to concede that Fits is a recognised writer? Done. Good point. Well made.
I think I have to be chardonnay socialist first though.
I thought not
LOOK AT ME, LOOK AT ME!!!
disguised as a blog post about something otherwise.
Thank you ms Fitz for your post. You have captured the ludicrous essence of a plummy toff in tweeds decrying the "elitism" of the forum.
Thanks also Booky and PerseusQ for reminding everyone that "Elites" is just a term of abuse that the previous government used to reassure "Battlers" that "Liberals" love the working class.
Total shite, and Voted Out by "the great mainstream".
Now the old dog's gone
.. and Alex just ain't got it.
Like being abused by a ball of wool, innit!
I don’t see AD as elite in any field
Simply put, they are born into it.
"pray, how the fuck is fits a member of the cultural elite?"
I'm pretty sure someone suppourting the argument that Ms Fit's is in fact an Elitist (which I am not) would claim that she was also born into it.
"You'd be amazed at how many artists come from working class backgrounds.
Therefore, quite a lot of your supposed 'elite culture' is supplied by the working class. And the working class is hardly 'elite."
You're missing the point. The pseudo-marxist theory is simply that the rich get more opportunities or 'life-chances' and are therefore more likely to become successful. Not necessarily that they are the only individuals that can become sucessful.
But keep in mind, once an artist accomplishes what we would call 'success' they are usually absorbed into the social elite and are therefore no longer considered working class.
Money is not the only thing that seperate levels of the hierachy, power and influence are usually just as important.
just like the stupid voters.
ha.
I'll stop now before I start sounding like a member of the Fits ass licker patrol.
I propose the 2020 summit be referred to as the "cohors milliaria of elites".
Why no, I don't think calling them that makes you sound elitist.
Oh, I think you might be. I'm calling your bluff. You are here only to 'have a go'. Which I'm sure is fine, just don't pretend you're not.
How you interpret it is up to you.
That's why I always hang out with, say, Adam Cullen and Ronnie Tjampitjinpa at the Melbourne Club* (although Tracey Moffatt does have a pretty flash pad...).
*do they let women in now?
"You'd be amazed at how many artists come from working class backgrounds."
That's funny
Most of those Liberal voters will have "moved on" by the next general election.
Fishnets has really fallen on hard times. Last year he was defending the enormous fuckup in Iraq, this year he is addressing a crowd that makes a CWA meeting look like a rave party.
Further I feel the reverand may have his own popular blog and occassionally come here to see how his student is progressing. Rev, love your work.
Gee sounds like she's describing the 2020 summit!
...
...
...
You know that deafening silence you hear after someone says something really stupid?
Comments are closed.